7 Min Read
Screens don't exactly make for a riveting conversation, but when you're trying to decide what's best for your home, suddenly it's top of mind. And lucky for you, we love talking about all things outdoor enclosures—including screens.
Do you want a motorized screen that gives you control at the touch of a button, or would a traditional screen be a better fit for your needs?
We're breaking down the pros and cons of motorized retractable screens and traditional options. Whether you're planning for a motorized patio screen, screen lanai, or screen room, we’ve got the info you need to make the right choice (and to save your friends from talking about screens)!
What is a Traditional or Fixed Screen?
A traditional or fixed screen is a permanent screen that stays in place year-round. It’s installed directly into the frame of your screen enclosure, screen room, or patio, providing constant protection from bugs and outdoor elements. Unlike retractable screens, these remain in place without any options for retraction.
What Are the Benefits of Traditional Screens?
Traditional screens are a more affordable, simple option for homeowners looking for basic protection. Let’s take a look at why they’re still a popular choice for many.
Lower Cost
Traditional screens are much more budget-friendly compared to motorized retractable screens. Since there’s no need for motors or electronic components, the upfront costs are significantly lower. However, this comes with a trade-off: you’ll always be confined to the screen without the flexibility to open up your space to the outdoors.
No Power Needed
Because traditional screens are fixed, they don’t require any electricity. This means no complicated wiring or the need for a power source near your screen porch or patio. It’s as low-maintenance as it gets, with no worry about electrical components failing or needing replacement. However, if you're planning for lighting or ceiling fans in your screen enclosure, you'll already have electricity in the vicinity, making for easier access.
More Screen Material Options
With traditional screens, you can choose from a variety of materials. Options include fiberglass, aluminum, polyester, and pet-resistant mesh. This flexibility allows you to customize your enclosure to meet your specific needs, whether you're focusing on budget, durability, or aesthetics.
What Are the Drawbacks of Traditional Screens?
While traditional screens have their advantages, they also come with notable limitations. Let’s break down some of the key drawbacks.
Permanently Fixed
Once installed, traditional screens are permanent fixtures in your outdoor space. This means you don’t have the flexibility to open up the area to the outdoors, which can feel restrictive if you enjoy a more open, breezy atmosphere. There’s no way to retract or remove the screen without disassembling it.
Limited Airflow
With traditional screens, you won’t have much control over airflow. When the screen is in place, you’re locked into that setup, which means you can't let more fresh air in or adjust the space for outdoor breezes. This can make your outdoor area feel more enclosed than you might like, especially on nice days when you want a more open space.
Lack of Flexibility
Unlike motorized retractable screens, traditional screens don’t offer flexibility for different activities. Whether you’re entertaining guests or just want to enjoy the outdoors without barriers, you’re stuck with the screen being permanently in place. It’s either all or nothing.
How Long Do Traditional Screens Last?
Traditional screens usually last 5-20 years, depending on the material and the climate. For example, fiberglass screens may wear out more quickly than polyester screens due to their lower durability. However, with proper care and maintenance, traditional screens can serve you well for many years.
How Much Do Traditional Screens Cost?
Traditional screens are priced by the square foot. Screens typically cost around $9-$12 per square foot. Specialty materials like pet-resistant or solar screens can range higher, but overall, traditional screens are an affordable option.
A Traditional Screen Might Be Right for You If...
Traditional screens are a good option if you’re looking for something budget-friendly and don’t mind a fixed enclosure. They’re perfect for those who don’t need the added flexibility of motorized retractable screens or prefer a low-maintenance solution that doesn’t require power. If simplicity and cost are your priorities, a traditional screen is the way to go.
What is a Motorized Screen?
A motorized screen is a retractable screen system that operates with the push of a button or via a smartphone app. These screens are mounted on a frame and can be raised or lowered as needed, providing flexibility for outdoor spaces like screen rooms or screen lanais.
What Are the Benefits of Motorized Screens?
Motorized screens offer significant advantages in convenience, flexibility, and aesthetics. Let’s explore the key benefits.
Creates a Seamless Transition
One of the biggest perks of a motorized patio screen is the ability to completely open up your outdoor space. When retracted, your space seamlessly blends with the outdoors, perfect for hosting gatherings or enjoying a more expansive view. When needed, you can simply lower the screen for protection from bugs or the sun.
Control at the Touch of a Button
No need to manually adjust anything—motorized screens give you control with the push of a button or even from your smartphone. Whether you want to lower the screen for privacy or raise it to enjoy the breeze, it’s all effortless. It’s a major convenience compared to manual roll-up screens for porches.
Peak Privacy
Motorized screens offer excellent privacy when you need it. Hosting a private dinner or simply want to relax? With just the touch of a button, you can lower your screen and enjoy a peaceful, private space.
Ability to Convert Space at Will
With motorized retractable screens, you have the ability to convert your space as needed. If you’re entertaining guests or want to keep an eye on the kids playing outside, you can open up or close your space at any time, offering flexibility that traditional screens don’t provide.
What Are the Drawbacks of Motorized Screens?
While motorized outdoor screens are incredibly convenient, there are a few downsides to consider.
You'll Need A Power Source
Unlike traditional screens, motorized retractable screens require a power source. This will add to your installation costs and limit where the screens can be installed. However, the added convenience may be well worth the investment.
Fewer Screen Material Options
Motorized screens come with fewer material options compared to traditional screens. While you can still choose from durable materials like solar screens, insect-resistant screens, or hurricane screens, there isn’t as much variety.
Each Panel Can Only Be So Big
Each panel of a motorized screen can only get so large. While these screens can cover significant areas—up to 25 feet wide—you may require multiple panels for larger spaces. However, even with these limitations, motorized screens are still an excellent solution for most homeowners.
Needs to Be Installed by an Experienced Professional
Due to the complexity of motorized screens, professional installation is a must. This ensures that the system works properly and lasts a long time, particularly in harsh weather conditions. While this adds to the overall motorized screen porch cost, it guarantees that your investment is well-protected.
How Long Do Motorized Screens Last?
Motorized screens are built to last, especially with high-quality brands like Magnatrack™. Most systems offer warranties that cover aluminum components for a lifetime, motors for 5 years, and fabrics for up to 10 years. With proper maintenance, you can expect your motorized screen to last for many years.
How Much Do Motorized Screens Cost?
On average, motorized retractable screens range from $5,000 to $6,500, depending on the size, materials, and customization. For a more detailed breakdown and what you can expect to be included, check out our full guide on motorized screen costs.
A Motorized Screen Might Be Right for You If...
If you’re looking for flexibility, convenience, and a modern solution, motorized screens are a great investment. They offer more control over your space, making them ideal for homeowners who want the option to open up or enclose their outdoor areas at will.
You're Looking for More Control
The ability to open and close your space with the push of a button offers ultimate control. Whether you want to block the sun, enjoy privacy, or simply let in a breeze, motorized screens give you the flexibility to do it all.
Your Priority is Ease and Flexibility
If convenience is key, motorized retractable screens are the way to go. They offer ease of use with the flexibility to convert your space in seconds, making them perfect for homeowners who value adaptability.
You're Looking for High ROI
Motorized screens are a high-end feature that can boost your home’s value. If you’re looking for a way to improve your outdoor space and increase your property’s marketability, motorized screens are the right choice.
Are Traditional Screens or Motorized Screens Better for Florida?
In Florida, motorized screens are the better option for dealing with the state’s harsh weather conditions. With the ability to retract and extend as needed, motorized screens offer better wind, sun, and bug protection. Plus, they provide extra privacy, making them ideal for pool enclosures and other outdoor areas.
Are Motorized Screens Worth It?
Yes! Motorized screens offer versatility, convenience, and added value to your home. Whether you’re looking to control sunlight, enhance privacy, or just make outdoor living easier, motorized screens are a great investment.
How to Choose the Best Screen for Your Jacksonville Home
When deciding between traditional and motorized screens, here are a few factors to consider:
Think About Who Will Be Using the Space
Are you hosting large parties or looking for a space for quiet relaxation? Understanding who will be using the space most can help you determine whether traditional or motorized screens are right for you.
Does the Space Offer Access to Electricity?
Motorized screens require a power source, which could increase installation costs, especially if your outdoor space doesn’t already have electrical wiring nearby.
While adding power access adds to the initial cost, it makes the screen far more useful in the long run. You’ll be able to control it with the push of a button or through a phone app or on the structure itself, making your space adaptable to any situation.
How Do You Plan to Use the Space?
How you plan to use your outdoor space will also play a big role in deciding between traditional and motorized screens. If you want to host frequent gatherings or have the flexibility to open and close the space as needed, motorized screens are the way to go. However, if you're looking for something simple and budget-friendly just to keep out bugs, traditional screens might be more your style.
How to Choose the Best Screen Enclosure Contractor in Jacksonville
Now that you know the differences between traditional and motorized screens, the next step is finding the right contractor to install them. Here’s what to look for:
Read a Lot of Reviews
When searching for a screen enclosure contractor, start by reading reviews from past clients. A company with consistently positive feedback is more likely to deliver a great experience and high-quality results.
View Portfolios
Don’t just take their word for it—check out their previous work! A contractor’s portfolio should include a variety of completed projects, showcasing their ability to install motorized retractable screens or traditional screen enclosures that meet your needs.
Schedule Consultations
Before making your final decision, schedule consultations with a few different companies. This gives you the opportunity to ask questions, get pricing, and see if their approach matches your vision. A great contractor will take the time to walk you through the process and make sure you feel confident in your choice.
Ready to Find the Perfect Screen for Your Home?
Choosing between motorized screens and traditional screens doesn’t have to be a tough decision. By considering your budget, space needs, and how you plan to use your outdoor area, you can find the perfect solution to enhance your home. If you’re ready to get started or need more information, contact Impact Enclosures today for a quick consultation! We’ll help you choose the right screen and get the installation done with quality and care.
